Free shipping on 4-pint bundles · SHIPS FROZEN
Custom Pints · Shipped Frozen

Build a pint that's only yours.

Pick a base, pile on the mix-ins, name your creation. We churn it small-batch and ship it to your door in dry ice.

choose 4 mix-ins allergy-safe ✓ ship anywhere in the US name it yours
Your Pint
MIX IT IN
vanilla · cookies · cherries
How it works

Four steps. One perfect pint.

01

Pick a base

Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, or our dairy-free oat dream.

02

Add mix-ins

Cookies, candies, marshmallows, fresh fruit. Up to 4 per pint.

03

Name it

Silly, sweet, or serious — your pint gets the name it deserves.

04

Ship it

Packed in dry ice. Delivered cold to your door in 2–3 days.

Fan favorites

Try a starter, or design from scratch.

Built by customers, loved by everyone. Or skip these and build your own.

See all 12 flavors →

We started Mix It In because no two people crave the same pint. So we let you build yours.

Why Mix It In

Small batch. Big choice.

01

Yours, not ours

You pick the base, the mix-ins, even the name on the label. We just churn it.

02

Allergy-safe

Filter the menu by what you can't eat. Every pint shows what's in it, in plain language.

03

Shipped cold

Dry ice. Insulated box. Tracked all the way to your freezer. 2–3 day delivery anywhere in the US.

Your pint is waiting.

Build it in under two minutes. Eat it in even less.

Start building →
Questions?

The fine print.

How fast do you ship?

We ship Monday through Wednesday so your pints don't sit in transit over the weekend. Most orders arrive in 2–3 business days, packed in dry ice inside an insulated box.

What if I have a serious allergy?

All bases and mix-ins are clearly labeled for the top 5 allergens (milk, egg, peanut, tree nut, gluten). For severe allergies, please contact us — our facility handles dairy, eggs, gluten, and tree nuts, and we can't guarantee a zero cross-contamination environment.

How long do the pints last?

Stored in the freezer, your pints stay fresh for up to 60 days. They'll arrive frozen solid — just transfer to your freezer immediately.

Can I gift a pint to a friend?

Yes! At checkout, you can ship to any address and add a personalized note. Bundles of 4, 6, or 8 pints make great gifts.

What's your return policy?

If your pints arrive melted or damaged, we'll replace them at no cost. Just send us a photo within 48 hours of delivery.